Disclaimer: Every home is different. This ranking is meant for most homes in western South Dakota, but not all. Your budget, neighborhood, home style, and even your insurance company can influence the “best” choice. Always consult a trusted roofing contractor before deciding.
From our experience in the Black Hills, it’s also smart to replace your roof every ~15 years. We’ve removed plenty of roofs in Rapid City that looked fine from the street but were hiding rot, leaks, and damage that had gone unnoticed for years.
Below, we’ve broken down six of the most common roofing types their background, pros, cons, lifespan, cost ranges, and fit for Rapid City’s climate.
1. Class 3 & 4 Impact-Resistant Shingles (Best Overall Value)
What They Are:
Impact-resistant shingles look like regular asphalt shingles but are manufactured with stronger asphalt blends, fiberglass mesh, or polymer-modified asphalt to resist hail and debris. Class 4 is the highest rating, tested to withstand a 2-inch steel ball dropped from 20 feet.
Pros for Rapid City Homes:
Affordable protection compared to premium roofing.
Insurance discounts (some South Dakota insurers reduce premiums for Class 4 shingles).
Wide variety of colors and styles.
More resistant to hail, wind, and temperature swings than standard shingles.
Cons:
Not indestructible—extreme hailstorms can still cause damage.
Slightly higher cost than entry-level shingles.
Average Lifespan: 20–30 years in South Dakota.
Typical Cost (Installed): $450–$700 per 100 sq. ft.
Why We Rank Them #1: Class 4 shingles hit the sweet spot—reasonable price, great curb appeal, and the hail resistance Rapid City homeowners need.
2. Standing Seam Metal Roofing
What It Is:
A premium roofing system with vertical panels and raised seams. Fasteners are hidden, reducing leak points.
Pros:
40–70 year lifespan.
Hidden fasteners = fewer leaks.
Reflective coatings reduce heat absorption in hot summers.
Excellent wind resistance.
Clean, modern curb appeal.
Cons:
Expensive (often double or triple shingles).
Requires skilled installation.
Can be noisy in heavy rain or hail (though underlayment helps).
Average Lifespan: 40–70 years.
Typical Cost (Installed): $1,400–$2,400 per 100 sq. ft.
Why It’s #2: Standing seam is the “forever roof” if you can budget for it.
3. Euroshield Rubber Roofing
What It Is:
Shingles made from recycled rubber, often designed to mimic slate or wood shakes.
Pros:
Extremely hail-resistant (designed to handle up to 4-inch hail).
Eco-friendly, made mostly from recycled tires.
Flexible, won’t crack or split.
Cheaper than standing seam metal.
Cons:
Limited colors and styles.
Fades unevenly over time.
Some homeowners dislike the look or faint tire smell when new.
Average Lifespan: 40–50 years.
Typical Cost (Installed): $800–$1,600 per 100 sq. ft.
Why It’s #3: Excellent hail protection, but not as common or widely loved aesthetically.
4. Standard Asphalt Shingles
What They Are:
The most common roofing in North America for decades.
Pros:
Cheapest option upfront.
Easy to install and replace.
Wide selection of colors and designs.
Cons in Rapid City:
Vulnerable to hail and storm damage.
Shorter lifespan than other materials.
Requires more frequent repairs.
Average Lifespan: 15–20 years in South Dakota.
Typical Cost (Installed): $400–$550 per 100 sq. ft.
Why It’s #4: Budget-friendly but not ideal for hail-heavy regions like ours.
5. Ribbed Panel Metal Roofing (Exposed Fastener)
What It Is:
Corrugated or ribbed metal panels screwed directly into the roof deck with thousands of exposed fasteners.
Pros:
Durable and wind-resistant.
Lower cost than standing seam.
Easy to source in rural South Dakota.
Cons:
Rubber washers on screws wear out and cause leaks.
Industrial or agricultural look (not ideal for most homes).
Can dent from hail.
Average Lifespan: 40–60 years with maintenance.
Typical Cost (Installed): $700–$1300 per 100 sq. ft.
Why It’s #5: Works for barns or shops, but not the best option for a home.
6. Stone-Coated Steel Roofing
What It Is:
Steel panels coated with stone granules to mimic shake, tile, or shingles.
Pros:
Attractive, upscale look.
Long-lasting and impact resistant.
Cons:
Very expensive.
Hard to justify cost when Class 4 shingles or standing seam perform as well for less.
Average Lifespan: 40–60 years.
Typical Cost (Installed): $1,800–$2,700 per 100 sq. ft.
Why It’s #6: Beautiful but pricey, with better value options available.
Final Thoughts for Black Hills Homeowners
Homes in western South Dakota face unique weather challenges: hail, heavy snow, strong winds, and big temperature swings.
Best value: Class 4 impact-resistant shingles.
Longest lifespan: Standing seam metal.
Best hail protection: Euroshield rubber.
Budget option: Standard shingles.
If you’re in Rapid City, Box Elder, Summerset, Spearfish, or anywhere in the Black Hills, Built Right Roofing & Construction offers free, honest roof inspections including hail damage reports for your insurance company.
Tags
Subscribe to Built Right Roofing & Construction's Blog
Comments